Do you have to choose between moving fast with AI and protecting your company?
Many executive teams experience the question exactly like that. On one side are new tools, pilot projects and the pressure not to fall behind. On the other side are data protection, security and a core business that has to work every single day. Wanting both at once looks like spreading yourself too thin.
At its IT Symposium in October, Gartner shared a sobering figure with more than 7,500 CIOs and IT leaders. 86 percent of CIOs see the risk of AI in their organisation growing faster than its value. In a separate Gartner survey of 303 CIOs and IT risk leaders, only 25 percent said they effectively align technology and business risks. Even so, the analysts did not recommend hitting the brakes. Value and risk belong together and have to be aligned.
Gartner describes this as a flywheel with two forces, momentum and drag. One drives you forward, the other holds you back. There is no universally right ratio. The right balance depends on your own strategy and your own appetite for risk. That is exactly what makes it a leadership question rather than an IT question.
🐛 The problem: two camps that block each other
In many companies, innovation and preservation are two departments with two logics. One wants to experiment, the other wants to safeguard. One measures speed, the other measures incidents. In the end whoever is louder decides, and the result is either sprawl or standstill.
I know this tension from the inside. For five years I was Head of Digitalisation and security officer at the same time, in an internationally active industrial group. I implemented digital strategies, built a digital team and was responsible for information security according to standards such as ISO 27001 and TISAX. If you wear both hats, you cannot hide behind the other camp.
Since then I have been convinced that the either-or is usually a question of organisation, not of substance.
I am seeing what this looks like today at a software company I am supporting. It is introducing AI-assisted development methods and realising that its existing structures and skills were not designed for them. Work on the agentic harness, the framework in which AI agents take part in development, is moving quickly. That is the momentum. The drag lies elsewhere: in the chain all the way to the customers. Development is getting faster, but the company as a whole first has to learn to handle that pace.
🦋 The solution: both-and, designed on purpose
Cars need good brakes to drive fast. Innovation and preservation work the same way. Organisations that have understood this call it ambidexterity: the core business is run carefully, and at the same time there is room for something new.
So that this does not remain a buzzword, four habits help:
🦋 Decide together: digitalisation and security sit at the same table from the start, not only at sign-off.
🦋 Think in layers: first clarify which capability is needed, then the processes, then the data and only at the very end the technology. The 4-layer model by thinking services (in German) shows how this fits together. On every layer you can ask what may be created anew and what has to be protected.
🦋 Grade risk by data: not every application needs the same rules. Without personal data you can experiment more than with health data.
🦋 Enable people: Gartner's Daryl Plummer said, in essence, that governance creates safety but not value. Only people create value. If you enable your employees, you gain both.
What this could look like
An industrial SME with 150 employees wants to use AI for preparing quotes. Instead of a fundamental dispute between sales and IT, a small team from both areas meets. It first clarifies what benefit quote preparation should deliver. Then it looks at which data is needed and how it is classified. Prices and customer names stay in a protected environment, general product descriptions may go into a more widely available tool. After four weeks there is a first pilot and a short rule everyone understands. Innovation and preservation are not opponents here, but two sides of the same decision.
Benefits at a glance
🦋 Faster decisions, because objections are on the table early
🦋 Less shadow IT, because there is a permitted path
🦋 Security that enables the new instead of preventing it
🦋 A core business that stays stable while something new emerges
Conclusion
Innovation without preservation becomes a risk, preservation without innovation becomes standstill. Whoever deliberately combines the two reaches the goal faster and more safely.
👉 Where do innovation and preservation already sit at the same table in your company, and where not yet? We are happy to support you, for example with an assessment as part of the Reisepass.
(AI generated)